Rules to Know for American Express Credit Card Applications

There are three major rules to know before applying for an American Express credit card:

  1. Once in a lifetime bonus

  2. 1 in 5

  3. 2 in 90

One thing to be aware of, if you are not currently an American Express customer, don't apply until you get targeted for a great offer. A lot of Amex card members are frustrated because they aren't targeted for great offers like new customers, but it's a user acquisition strategy for Amex. 

The highest offer I've seen is 100,000 bonus points for the Amex Platinum card. CardMatch is a common way to find increased offers. Again, it depends on your timing if you want to hold out for the offer or not. The higher offers are usually targeted and not publicly available.

Before we dive into the core rules, there are a few prerequisites to be aware of to see if you’re eligible for welcome offers.

Welcome Offer Clawbacks

American Express updated their terms of service in 2018 by adding “anti-churning” language. Amex reserves the right to “clawback” a welcome offer if they detect any “gaming” activity like peer-to-peer payments, cash equivalent gift cards, and closing accounts early.

Peer-to-peer (P2P) payments is when you send money to a friend via a service like PayPal. However, if you make a purchase from a retail merchant with PayPal, this is a normal transaction. Amex has access to third-level data so they can distinguish between P2P and merchant payments.

Cash equivalents are another type of purchase that can raise a red flag. These can be in the form of Visa or American Express gift cards purchased from a drug store or any other retailer that sells them. Again, Amex has access to third-level data so they know when you’re purchasing cash equivalent gift cards.

Closing a new account before the 12-month mark is another red flag. When you try to close an account that’s less than a year old, it seems like you’re only opening the account for the welcome offer. Closing the account early means that Amex reserves the right to claw back the welcome bonus. Keep the card for at least 12 months and you can cancel or downgrade afterward if you don’t want it.

Welcome Offer Eligibility

If you sign up for a card and you get a pop up saying that you're not eligible for a welcome bonus, you will not receive one.

There are 2 theories:

  1. You’re blacklisted from Amex from doing one of the activities in the previous section about “Welcome Offer Clawbacks.”

  2. You’re not putting enough spend on your cards in recent months; Amex doesn’t see you as a person that needs another charge or credit card if your cards current cards with them are idle.

Once in a lifetime signup bonus

If you've ever had a certain Amex product past or present, regardless of if you received a signup bonus, you will not be eligible for the signup bonus again. The sole act of having X card means you will not be eligible for the signup bonus. 

For example, if you had the Amex Everday card in the past and canceled it (or product change), you would not be eligible to receive another Amex Everyday signup bonus if you applied for it again in the future. 

Another example would be if you opened the Hilton Ascend card and downgraded it to the no annual fee Hilton Honors card. By downgrading it, you lose out on the 75k to 100k Hilton Honors bonus that's pretty normal for the Hilton -- easily 1 night in most of their expensive properties like Bora Bora, Maldives, or Koh Samui

Technically, we have seen some offers that don't have this once in a lifetime language, but it's not common. I would argue that this is the biggest core strategy to work around -- especially for new people thinking about upgrades/downgrades.

However, cards like the Amex Platinum card have different variations, which are all considered different products. You could receive the signup bonus for each variation of the Amex Platinum card. 

5 Credit Card Limit

Some data points suggest that you can only have 5 American Express credit cards at one time, regardless if it’s a personal or business card. Your mileage may vary.

If you’re currently at the 5 Amex credit card limit and you want to open a new Amex credit card, you’ll have to call in and close an account in order to open a new one.

Important note: Charge cards are NOT the same as credit cards. You can have as many charge cards as you want (Amex Platinum, Gold, Green).

Again, this is rule only applies to credit cards — 4 personal and 1 business, or 5 business credit cards— whatever other combination you want.

The 5 credit card rule is key depending on your card play style and strategy. if you're optimizing for cash back, then there's less to worry about. If you're hunting for bonuses, then you don't want to "lock up" one of your slots for no reason.

1 in 5 Rule

You can only get approved for one credit card every five days.

The 1 in 5 rule doesn’t affect charge cards, so you could apply for one credit card and X charge cards on the same day and be fine. Keep in mind that you’ll have to manage the minimum spend requirements.

Applying for multiple American Express cards doesn’t have a big impact on your credit score because once you have one Amex card, they typically only do soft pulls after that. Your mileage may vary.

2 in 90 Rule

You can only get approved for two credit cards every 90 days. This means that if you apply for a third card within the 90-day window, you'll automatically be rejected. 

These rules apply to credit cards only and not charge cards, so you can apply for as many charge cards as you like. 

Welcome Offer Matches

American Express typically doesn’t match welcome offers. For example, if you apply for the Amex Delta Gold credit card with a 30,000 welcome offer, and the next week it increases to 60,000 points, Amex is unlikely to match it.

Optimal Strategy

Given the rules and restrictions, the optimal strategy would apply for a charge card and a credit card on the same day to combine hard pulls. This means you will only have one credit inquiry, as opposed to two.

If you don’t currently hold any American Express cards, I recommend checking CardMatch to see if you can get targeted for the 100k Platinum card offer.

Be aware that if you have more than a $35,000 cumulative credit limit with Amex, it will trigger a financial review. Your accounts will be frozen during the financial review. 

Amex will not match any increased offers. For example, if you applied for a card with a 50,000 point offer, and the next week a 60,000 point offer pops up, they will not match the offer. 

If you apply for a card and you're rejected, you can always call the reconsideration line to speak to an agent to look into your profile. Calling the reconsideration line will not help you bypass any rules.